New facilities open and on the way for Bomaderry High School

Students in Bomaderry have started Term 4 in their new world-class public school facilities three months ahead of schedule, following a recently-completed stage of an upgrade for Bomaderry High School.

Member for Kiama Katelin McInerney officially opened the school’s new Technological and Applied Studies (TAS) building, with home economics and industrial arts lessons underway in new workshops for woodwork, metalwork, and food technology.

Bomaderry students will now be able to use the new facilities to learn contemporary skills on industry-standard equipment, providing a pathway for students to tertiary education and employment in the region.

Students and staff are already benefiting from major improvements, with a new administration office and refurbishment works to two buildings—including the installation of two new lifts to enhance accessibility—now complete and in use.

Further upgrades at Bomaderry High School are on the way, including the refurbishment of almost 50 existing classrooms and the installation of a new vocational education kitchen.

For over a decade, the former Liberal National government neglected public schools on the South Coast and failed to deliver the Bomaderry High School upgrades, despite promising to do so in 2021.

The upgrade to Bomaderry High School is among 12 new schools and major upgrades being delivered across the Illawarra and Shoalhaven region, including:

  • Calderwood – new public school and public preschool
  • Dapto High School – new covered outdoor learning area
  • Flinders – new high school
  • Milton Public School – upgrade
  • Minnamurra Public School – new nature playground
  • Nowra East Public School – upgrade
  • Ulladulla High School – upgrade
  • Ulladulla Public School – upgrade
  • Vincentia High School – upgrade
  • West Dapto – new public school and public preschool
  • Worrigee – new public school and public preschool

The Minns Labor Government is also building nine additional new public preschools in the region, offering more than 700 places per week for the area’s youngest learners.

The public preschools will be co-located with Barrack Heights, Berkeley West, Bomaderry, Cringila, Greenwell Point, Hayes Park, Lake Heights, Lake Illawarra South, and Sanctuary Point public schools.

These upgrades reflect the NSW Government’s commitment to delivering better schools for NSW students. The 2025–26 Budget includes a record $9 billion investment in school infrastructure, with $2.1 billion allocated to new and upgraded schools in regional NSW.

Alongside the Minns Labor Government’s investment in education infrastructure, we are making sure there are more teachers in front of students in NSW classrooms and have reduced teacher vacancies by 96 per cent in the electorate of Kiama.

Acting Minister for Education and Early Learning Courtney Houssos said:

“These upgrades represent our significant investment in the Bomaderry community and will deliver long-term benefits for local students and their families.

“For far too long, families on the South Coast were promised new schools and upgrades that never progressed past a media release by the Liberals.

“The Minns Labor Government, with the leadership of Deputy Premier Prue Car, is committed to building better public schools for our children.”

Member for Kiama Katelin McInerney said:

“It is crucial that our students have access to a world-class public education, and that is being delivered.

“Our government is investing in ensuring students learn in the best quality learning environment possible, have access to modern, industry-standard equipment that sets them up for success in their learning and the workforce, and an education experience that builds their belief in themselves so they can go out and make our community an even better place.”

Bomaderry High School Principal Ian Morris said:

“These new upgrades are just brilliant. Importantly our students can see that the equipment and facilities they have are absolutely world class.

“Our students are excited by them and the new office at the front of the school is a game changer for our community.

“Our support staff feel more valued as their workplace has been completely modernised, and our students will leave school with experience using industry-standard hospitality, woodwork and metalwork equipment.

“This level of support for regional education is just fantastic and welcomed by our entire school community.”

Minns Labor Government unlocks millions for rare earths and copper exploration to meet surging global demand

The Minns Labor Government is positioning NSW to be a global leader and industry partner in the race for critical minerals, rare earths elements and high-tech metals by supporting millions of dollars of investment in exploration.

The NSW Government has announced grants that will facilitate around $5 million of funding for 29 exploration projects to undertake drilling, geophysics and geochemistry exploration and find the next major critical minerals project.

Under the Critical Minerals and High Tech Metals Exploration Program, the NSW Government will provide almost $2.5 million in co-investment funding to the 29 projects. Explorers must then match it to receive the funding.

By partnering with the mining industry to pursue exploration, we can help discover more deposits of the critical minerals needed to manufacture modern technologies, including electric vehicles, mobile phones and solar panels.

Global demand for copper is rising rapidly, with prices climbing more than 20% this year. NSW is stepping up to meet this demand. Copper production in the state has increased by a third over the past three years, to around 190,000 tonnes this financial year.

With 21 of the 29 projects focused on copper exploration, this investment builds on NSW’s position as an industry partner and leading global supplier, and helps unlock new deposits to support the electrification of the economy, as well as AI data centres, clean energy technologies and infrastructure.

As demand for rare earth elements – naturally occurring metallic elements with powerful magnetic properties – grows in strategic importance, NSW is also supporting its exploration and production.

New exploration being supported by this round of funding is targeting opportunities for rare earth elements and zirconium.

Other minerals being targeted for exploration include silver and cobalt, vital to renewable energy technologies, manufacturing, infrastructure, and advanced medical equipment and diagnostics tools.

Successful applicants in the Critical Minerals and High-Tech Metals Exploration Program include:

  • Waratah Minerals to undertake drilling activities to explore for copper at the Spur Porphyry Project in the renowned Macquarie Arc. Waratah Minerals previously discovered one of the most significant copper-gold deposits in NSW in the last decade.
  • Neo Double Eagle Resources will explore for rare earth elements crucial in the production of smartphones, electric vehicles, wind turbines and defence technologies, with drilling activities at Binge Grumble Mountain.
  • Alkane Resources will undertake drilling activities in the Central West using a new exploration model suggesting that hidden deep beneath the historic gold mines at Peak Hill may lie undiscovered copper resources. This project demonstrates that underexplored areas exist underneath known historic deposits.
  • Silverton Minerals will be employing an innovative, low-impact technology which passively measures the natural electromagnetic fields in an exploration area generated by distant lightning strikes to identify possible mineral-bearing structures beneath the ground northwest of Broken Hill.

Exploration is critical in the early stages of any mining project. Intense and highly scientific activities are required to confirm the strength of a mineral deposit and its viability before a company can consider going through the planning process.

Already, there are approximately 1500 exploration titles currently being explored for minerals across the state, and this funding will further aid the search for the next big critical minerals, high-tech metals or rare earth elements deposit.

There are currently 15 active major metals and critical minerals mines across NSW, employing more than 6,000 people, mostly across the Central West and Far West.

The announcement comes as NSW prepares to host the International Mining and Resources Conference (IMARC), the largest international mining event in the Southern Hemisphere, with more than 10,000 delegates from 120 countries set to participate in Sydney this week.

The NSW Government is also hosting the Critical Minerals Investment Showcase, promoting investment-ready projects across the state to global funders from Europe, the Middle East, India, Korea and Japan.

This funding round is a key pillar of the NSW Government’s Critical Minerals and High-Tech Metals Strategy which is driving new investment in critical minerals and high-tech metals exploration production, processing and manufacturing.

Successful projects will commence exploration in coming months, advancing the search for critical minerals and high-tech metals needed to support future industries and power our way to Net Zero. 

Further information about the successful projects and recipients is available at Critical Minerals and High-Tech Metals Exploration Program.

Minister for Natural Resources Courtney Houssos:

“NSW has the critical minerals and high-tech metals that the world needs to drive a clean energy future, create new jobs, and build resilient supply chains.

“Whether it’s the copper we need for data centres, antimony for batteries, or the rare earth elements for electric vehicles,  NSW has the opportunity be at the centre of the critical minerals boom.

“These co-investment grants highlight the Minns Labor Government’s partnering with industry, and for NSW to be a leading player in the global race for critical minerals.

“NSW has an abundance of critical minerals and high-tech metals waiting to be discovered. We’re supporting miners and explorers alike to boost supply of these strategically important resources. 

“This is the biggest round of exploration funding ever offered in NSW. From exploration to production, we are supporting targeted initiatives at each stage of the project pipeline.”

Global streaming spotlight lands on NSW live music venues

Live music venues will get an important boost from a new Spotify ‘Venue Pages’ feature after calls from the Minns Labor Government to prioritise NSW for the rollout.

Sydney will join New York, London, and Paris as one of the first cities in the world to benefit from this new feature. This is the result of direct discussions between the Minns Labor Government and Spotify AUNZ about bringing more of the benefits of music streaming to local venues and artists.

Launching today across nine countries, Venue Pages will give NSW live music venues their own home on Spotify, to list their gigs to make it easier for fans to go from streaming their favourite artists to buying tickets and seeing them live. Features include:

  • Dedicated venues pages which allow users to search for venues, follow their favourites, save them to their libraries, access their gig guides, show details and new announcements.
  • A live events feed updated daily, delivering show recommendations curated on user location, listening habits, and venues followed.
  • Direct link from Spotify venue listings to official ticketing partner to securely purchase tickets, creating a quick link between music discovery and live music experiences.
  • Spotify will run an on-platform marketing campaign and educations sessions for NSW venues in the weeks following tomorrow’s announcement.

Working with Spotify to increase its positive impact on the local live music scene is part of a wider set of initiatives from the Minns Labor Government to support the industry as it faces challenges from cost increases, changing audience habits and an increase in local audiences streaming overseas artists. Key measures have included the establishment of a $160,000 prize pool for the NSW Music Prize and the adoption of Michael’s Rule which incentivises international artists to book an Australian support act.

The NSW Government will continue to work with Spotify AUNZ on the roll out and will also support local venues with training to maximise their engagement with this new feature.

Minister for Music and the Night-time Economy John Graham said: 

“We applaud Spotify for bringing Venue Pages to Australia and expect it to drive more local listeners to local gigs, which is great news.

“We’ve been working with Spotify, discussing ways they can use their immense global power to boost our local music scene. Streaming has sometimes hurt the local music scene, but this is a turning point where Spotify is increasing its support for it.

“Our local live music scene is the talent factory for the future of NSW music, but local gigs and venues have been under cost and demand pressures. This boost from Spotify is extremely welcome and dovetails perfectly with all the other support we’re delivering.

“Spotify helps Australian artists reach overseas audiences, but local audiences have increasingly been drawn to overseas artists. This initiative helps swing more of the benefits of Spotify to local artists and venues, which is much welcomed.” 

Alicia Sbrugnera, Head of Music at Spotify AUNZ, said:

“Venues are the foundation of a thriving local music scene, so giving venues a home on Spotify means helping fans to go from streaming their favourite artists to seeing them live.

“In the Australian rollout of Venue Pages, we’re excited to work closely with the NSW Government and the Minister for Music and Night-time Economy, John Graham, to support venues, artists, and Australian music.”

Pipeline repurposed to strengthen gas supply

The Minns Labor Government is supporting a more stable gas supply for NSW by backing the repurposing of an existing pipeline to transport gas from South Australia to the east coast of NSW.

The NSW Government has given APA Group the green light to convert its Moomba to Sydney Ethane Pipeline, adding stability to the gas network by making better use of existing infrastructure.

The approved licence variation allows for the conversion and unlocks the opportunity to deliver an extra 20-25 terajoules of gas per day, which is equal to the annual gas use of about 1,300 NSW homes.

This switch helps ensure a more reliable gas supply to meet existing needs, as the state increases renewable energy generation to replace ageing coal-fired power stations.

The 1,200km high-pressure pipeline has sat idle since 2023 when the previous single customer of the pipeline ceased operations.

APA Group proposed to repurpose the pipeline as part of its East Coast Gas Grid expansion program, a five-year initiative aimed at enhancing the transmission and storage capacity of natural gas across the east coast.

The decision to approve the licence variation followed a rigorous review of the safety, environmental and technical considerations involved in the project.

Gas from the repurposed pipeline is expected to be flowing by the end of the year, to help reduce the supply gap emerging across the east coast.

Minister for Climate Change and Energy, Penny Sharpe:

“This decision demonstrates the Minns Labor Government’s commitment to maintaining a reliable supply of gas while we transition to a cleaner, more sustainable energy system.

“The plan to repurpose the pipeline is a short-term measure that will boost gas supply to the east coast and complements the other work we are doing to manage supply risks and price issues.”

Northern Rivers residents share their resilient ideas & stories on film

Northern Rivers residents will take their adaptation stories to the big screen this week as part of the Adaptation Stories short films initiative.

Produced and curated by Living Lab Northern Rivers, in partnership with the NSW Reconstruction Authority, Adaptation Stories captures eight Northern Rivers locals as they navigate real change in response to the shifting climate.

Each film captures personal journeys of resilience and creativity, showcasing how individuals are thinking about what adaptation can mean for themselves and their communities.

From farmer-led strategies in Richmond Valley, to arts-based perspectives in Lismore, youth engagement in regenerative futures in Tweed, and lessons we can learn from Country in Byron, each film explores diverse approaches to adaptation across the region.

Adaption Stories is part of the Community Conversations engagement initiative supporting the Northern Rivers Disaster Adaptation Plan (DAP) currently being developed by the NSW Reconstruction Authority, with the films aiming to spark conversations among community.

Free screenings will be held at Woodburn, Byron Bay, Grafton, Lismore, Uki and Ballina from Thursday 23 October until December. At each screening, a Q&A session will be held with local community leaders. The first screening is at Woodburn on Thursday 23 October 2025.

For more details on screenings and locations visit https://events.humanitix.com/host/living-lab-northern-rivers.

Learn more about the Northern Rivers Disaster Adaptation Plan including how the community can get involved at www.nsw.gov.au/reducingrisk/NRdap.

Minister for Recovery and North Coast Janelle Saffin said:

“We need to shift the dial to properly focus on adaptation and resilience to ensure communities are better prepared for and can recover better from disasters.

“We are creating the first ever Disaster Adaptation Plan for the Northern Rivers and sharing stories and experiences is vital its success. 

“I encourage everyone – young and old, to please attend a screening and listen and share your thoughts and ideas, because it’s too important not to.”

Living Lab Northern Rivers: Engagement Director Dan Etheridge said:

“We don’t adapt alone, we adapt together. These short films have been made to get people talking with each other. I want to know what other people in my community are thinking about climate change adaptation and this is especially true when our government is developing a new plan to drive adaptation and reduce our exposure to disasters.”

Filmmaker and director Poppy Walker said:

“These stories reveal the thoughtful and diverse ways people are engaging in climate adaptation. When audiences hear their neighbours — Traditional Custodians, farmers, artists and business owners — sharing their perspectives on what adaptation could look like, it helps shape thinking and conversations around what we can do in our communities.” 

Northern Beaches Hospital

The NSW Opposition acknowledges today’s announcement by the NSW Government that Northern Beaches Hospital will return to full public ownership by mid-2026.
 
We recognise the extraordinary courage and persistence of Elouise and Danny Massa, whose advocacy following the tragic death of their son, Joe, has led to this significant change.
 
The Opposition has consistently supported measures to improve safety and transparency at Northern Beaches Hospital, including:
 

  • The Parliamentary Inquiry into the hospital’s performance,
  • The Coronial Inquest and Independent Review of the Emergency Department, and
  • The creation of Joe’s Law, to prevent any future public-private partnerships in acute care hospitals.

 
We have also supported the return of the public component of the hospital, including the emergency department, to full public control.
 
The Opposition also notes the concerns raised by doctors, the AMA, and the hospital’s Medical Advisory Committee about the future of private services under this arrangement.
 
The Northern Beaches community has one of the highest levels of private health insurance coverage in the state, and residents deserve reassurance that access to private care will not be diminished.
 
The Opposition remains ready to work cooperatively with the Government to ensure a smooth and safe transition that maintains choice, protects jobs, and delivers high-quality health care for the Northern Beaches community.

Apprenticeship collapse only worsens housing crisis under the Minns Labor Government

Apprenticeship and traineeship numbers have plunged across New South Wales, worsening the state’s housing crisis and leaving young people and small businesses without the skills needed to build the future.
 
New data from the National Centre for Vocational Education Research (NCVER) shows just over 42,000 apprentices and trainees commenced in the 12 months to March 2025.
 
This is the lowest level in more than five years.
 
The data also reveals more than 8,000 fewer apprentices are currently in training compared with the same period in 2024.
 
Leader of the Opposition Mark Speakman said the Minns Labor Government is failing to back the workers New South Wales needs.
 
“The Minns Labor Government promised to skill up the next generation, but instead they’re letting apprenticeship numbers fall off a cliff. Every lost apprentice means another young person missing out on a career and another builder, plumber or electrician not on the tools to build the homes families need,” Mr Speakman said.
 
Shadow Minister for Skills, TAFE and Tertiary Education Justin Clancy said the data is a warning sign for the future of housing and jobs in New South Wales.
 
“You can’t fix a housing shortage when there are fewer tradespeople to build homes. In just one year Labor has gone backwards on apprenticeships,” Mr Clancy said.
 
“The Government talks about adding 23,000 construction apprentices, but on these figures that’s simply not credible. Labor’s approach is failing young people who want a trade and employers who need skilled workers. The Minns Government needs to stop the spin and start delivering real results for skills, training and housing in New South Wales.”

Trump Shares Australia’s Feelings Towards Rudd

Overnight US President Donald Trump has told Kevin Rudd that “He doesn’t like him, and probably never will.” It is certainly a view of Rudd that most Australians agree with. 

One Nation has long called for Kevin Rudd’s recall from America. In fact, we’ve been calling for his recall from day one. Kevin Rudd doesn’t have the temperament or the talent to manage Australia–U.S. relations. His loose tongue has offended the very people who now hold the levers of power in Washington.

The disastrous U.S. trip by Anthony Albanese has exposed the problem: President Trump doesn’t like Kevin Rudd, and who could blame him?

Rudd is a loose-tongued fool, a self-important dunce with zero diplomatic skill and no ability to negotiate with the world’s leading superpower. His record as Prime Minister was a string of failures, and now he risks doing the same damage to one of our most important international relationships.

When in 2008 Prime Minister Rudd travelled to China and, in the host nation’s own language, delivered a lecture at Beijing University attacking China’s human rights record, he blew up our relationship with Beijing. That single undiplomatic, poorly timed speech triggered a two-decade decline in Australia–China relations. It showed exactly what Rudd has always been, a man who thinks he’s far cleverer than he really is.

The fact that Rudd remains in his post as U.S. Ambassador is proof of Anthony Albanese’s absolute inability to get anything right. While Trump was making it clear he didn’t trust or respect Rudd, Albanese was standing there grinning like a nervous schoolboy. Trump’s face was steely; he was dead serious.

Australia cannot maintain a strong relationship with the United States while this twerp, Kevin Rudd, continues in office.

If One Nation were in charge, Rudd would be sacked immediately. We’d appoint a capable, respected Ambassador to rebuild trust and lead the U.S.–Australia partnership with dignity. We’d also review the bloated staffing and perks Albanese handed Rudd as a former Prime Minister, a disgraceful use of public money for a man who delivers nothing but chaos and embarrassment.

It’s time to recall Kevin Rudd and restore some credibility to Australia’s diplomacy.

Historic critical minerals framework signed by President Trump and Prime Minister Albanese

Prime Minister Anthony Albanese and President of the United States Donald J. Trump today signed a landmark bilateral framework on critical minerals and rare earths at the White House in Washington DC. This will see an accelerated pipeline of priority projects delivered by and for the two nations.

The United States–Australia Framework for Securing of Supply in the Mining and Processing of Critical Minerals and Rare Earths will deliver a US/Australia secured supply chain for critical minerals and rare earths, required for defence and other advanced technologies. This represents a significant new chapter in the over 70 years of our formal Alliance.

Also announced today, to complement the Framework, the US and Australia will take measures to each provide at least USD$1 billion in investments towards an USD$8.5 billion pipeline of priority critical minerals projects in Australia and the United States over the next six months.

Two of those priority projects have financial commitments being announced today by the Australian Government. 

The first project is the Alcoa-Sojitz Gallium Recovery Project in Wagerup, Western Australia. 

Australia is announcing today up to USD$200 million in concessional equity finance for the project, which includes a right of offtake for the Australian Government. The United States Government is also making an equity investment with a right of offtake.

This project will provide up to 10 per cent of total global gallium supply. Gallium is an essential input for defence and semiconductor manufacturing. This is a trilateral project with Japan, the United States and Australia, which will strengthen our collective economic security. Japan has already provided 50 percent of the project costs to date.

The second project is the Arafura Nolans project in the Northern Territory. 

Australia is announcing today a USD$100 million equity investment in the project. Once operational, this project will produce 5 per cent of global rare earths – essential for energy security and defence.

The historic framework signed today will assist both countries in achieving resilience and security of critical minerals and rare earths supply chains, including mining, separation, and processing, through use of economic policy tools and coordinated investment.

US-Australia Critical Minerals Supply Security Response Group will be established under the leadership of the US Secretary of Energy and the Australian Minister for Resources to identify priority minerals and supply vulnerabilities and to develop a coordinated plan to accelerate delivery of processed minerals under this Framework.

Prime Minister Anthony Albanese:

There are no closer friends and allies than the United States of America and Australia.

“President Trump and I agreed today we will work very hard together in both our nations’ interests.

“We’ve agreed today Australia and America are going to make more things together with our historic framework on critical minerals.

“Australia is home to much of the periodic table of critical minerals and rare earth metals that are vital for defence and other advanced technologies.

“Cooperation on critical minerals and rare earth supply chains is testament to the trusted partnership between Australia and the United States as strategic defence allies.

“I look forward to continuing to work with President Trump to strengthen our partnership and support American and Australian workers, businesses and investors.”

31st Australia-Papua New Guinea Ministerial Forum

The Albanese Government will welcome Ministers from Papua New Guinea to Canberra today for the 31st Australia-Papua New Guinea Ministerial Forum. 

The Ministerial Forum co-hosted by Minister for Foreign Affairs, Senator the Hon Penny Wong and Papua New Guinea Minister for Foreign Affairs, the Hon Justin Tkatchenko BEM OL MP, follows the historic signing of the Papua New Guinea-Australia Mutual Defence Treaty – the Pukpuk Treaty – by Prime Minister Albanese and Prime Minister Marape.

The Treaty elevates our relationship to an Alliance, and reflects both countries’ commitment to each other and to a region that is peaceful, stable and prosperous.  

Building on decades of close collaboration, the Forum will further our engagement across the breadth of our shared priorities, including: 

  • Progression of the PNG-Australia Alliance through the establishment of a recruitment pathway that will enable PNG citizens to join the Australian Defence Force, and investments in infrastructure and common capabilities to support the Papua New Guinea Defence Force’s training initiatives.
  • A new education and skills package worth over $150 million to support PNG’s productivity, economic growth and human development. Delivered in partnership with the PNG Government and local organisations, the package includes four new investments focused on foundational education (early grades); secondary education; improving retention, particularly for girls; and Technical and Vocational Education and Training (TVET).
  • A $25 million humanitarian and disaster relief package which includes the construction of new humanitarian warehouses to strengthen PNG’s ability to respond to disasters across the country; a new twinning partnership between Australia’s National Emergency Management Agency (NEMA) and the PNG National Disaster Centre to enhance capacity building; and scoping for the construction of an emergency command and control centre in Port Moresby to monitor risks and better coordinate disaster response.  

In the year of PNG’s 50th anniversary of independence, we celebrate the deep friendship between our two nations, steeped in shared history and characterised by mutual respect and ongoing collaboration. 

The Ministerial Forum provides an opportunity for ministers across key policy areas to advance shared goals across our comprehensive strategic and economic partnership.

The delegation will also engage with Australian and Papua New Guinean private sector representatives through the Annual Australia-Papua New Guinea Business Dialogue, co-hosted by Australian Minister for Trade and Tourism, Senator the Hon Don Farrell, and PNG Minister for International Trade and Investment, The Hon Richard Maru OBE MP.  

Acting Prime Minister and Defence, Minister Richard Marles:   

“Our new Alliance is a natural evolution of our close and longstanding defence ties – one which supports sovereignty and safeguards the peace and security of our region.  

“We are working closely together as we move from defence partners to allies, building on decades of growing collaboration under our Defence Cooperation Program. I look forward to furthering those discussions with my good friends and colleagues during this Australia-PNG Ministerial Forum.”  

Foreign Minister, Penny Wong:  

This is a historic moment in the story of our two nations, Australia and Papua New Guinea; we are the oldest of friends, closest of neighbours, and soon-to-be, newest of allies.  

“Today, we take our first steps on the stewardship of our alliance and nurture our full breadth of interests to shape a peaceful, stable and prosperous Blue Pacific.  

“Australia and Papua New Guinea have never been closer, evidenced through the number of ministers we will have around the table today.”  

Minister for Pacific Island Affairs and Defence Industry, Pat Conroy:   

“We have always stood shoulder-to-shoulder with Papua New Guinea. We’re committed to strengthening our close economic, development and security partnership, and working with PNG to improve outcomes in education and training.  

“This Ministerial Forum builds on the momentum from the historic signing of the PNG-Australia Mutual Defence Treaty, our NRL deal, and our Bilateral Security Agreement that have elevated our relationship.”